Logic

I believe the cab driver would push the bad one towards me for several reasons. One, he admitted that he like the idea of killing people because he was able to say that he out lived 4 other people. Two, he kept saying that he was super smart and that was how he "won" all the other times. By moving one of the bottles toward me I would assume it was the good one because I would think that he was trying to trick me into believing that it was the bad one so I would reach for his, but instead I decide to keep mine. He figures that I might also come up with this theory so in actuality he gave me the bad one thinking that I would just keep it. Again this would leave the cab driver with the good bottle. I reason that he would try to double trick me.

//Ah, the double-bluff. I would like to have seen more detail in your explanation, as well as a mention of inductive or deductive reasoning--which are you using and when?//